Should you choose Incogni or DeleteMe for data removal?

Both Incogni and DeleteMe are solid data broker removal services, but they work differently. Incogni gives you detailed proof and control over removals, while DeleteMe handles everything automatically behind the scenes. Your choice really depends on whether you want to see exactly what's happening or prefer a hands-off approach.

Here's the thing - your personal information is probably scattered across hundreds of data broker websites right now. These sites collect and sell everything from your address and phone number to your shopping habits and political views. It's honestly pretty creepy when you think about it. Both services help clean up this mess, but they take different approaches to get the job done.

I've tested both services extensively, and there's no clear "winner" - it really comes down to your personality and what you value most. Let me break down how each one works so you can make the right choice for your situation.

How does each service actually work?

Incogni takes what I'd call the "show your work" approach. When you sign up, they immediately start scanning data broker sites to find your information. But here's what makes them different - they show you everything they find with actual screenshots. You can literally see your personal info on these sketchy websites before they remove it.

The dashboard is pretty detailed, maybe even overwhelming at first. You'll see every data broker they're monitoring, what information was found on each site, and the status of removal requests. They send you regular reports with screenshots proving your data has been removed. It's like having a paper trail for your privacy.

DeleteMe works more like a privacy concierge service. You give them your information, and they handle everything behind the scenes. You won't see detailed screenshots or get bombarded with technical reports. Instead, they send you clean, simple summaries every few months showing what they've accomplished.

Both services monitor hundreds of data broker sites, but they present the information very differently. DeleteMe focuses on peace of mind - you know the work is getting done without having to think about it. Incogni gives you transparency and control, which some people really appreciate but others find stressful.

The actual removal process is similar for both. They submit opt-out requests to data brokers on your behalf, follow up when sites don't respond, and continuously monitor for your information reappearing. Data brokers are legally required to honor these requests in most cases, but some are slower to respond than others.

What are the main differences between them?

The biggest difference is transparency. Incogni shows you everything - sometimes more than you want to see. You'll get notifications when new data appears, screenshots of your listings, and detailed progress reports. It's great if you're the type of person who likes to know exactly what's happening with your data.

DeleteMe keeps things simple and clean. Their reports focus on the big picture rather than individual site details. You'll know how many sites had your information and how many removals were completed, but you won't see the nitty-gritty details unless you specifically ask for them.

Pricing is another key difference. Incogni offers a free scan so you can see what's out there before paying anything. Their paid plans start around $9 per month and go up based on how many data brokers they monitor. DeleteMe is more expensive at around $129 per year, but they include more comprehensive monitoring from the start.

Coverage varies between the services too. Both monitor major data broker sites, but they don't cover exactly the same list. Incogni tends to focus on sites that are more likely to have detailed personal information, while DeleteMe casts a wider net that includes some smaller, less significant brokers.

Customer support is handled differently as well. Incogni provides more self-service options and detailed FAQs, which works well if you like figuring things out yourself. DeleteMe offers more hand-holding and personal assistance, which is helpful if you prefer talking to actual humans when you have questions.

Which service works better in practice?

I've been using both services for several months now, and they're both effective at what they do. The question isn't really which one "works better" - it's which approach fits your personality and needs.

Incogni found more of my information initially, probably because their scanning is more aggressive. But seeing all those screenshots of my data on random websites was honestly a bit disturbing. Some people love having this level of detail, but it can be anxiety-inducing if you're already worried about privacy.

DeleteMe's approach felt less overwhelming. I knew they were working on my behalf, but I wasn't constantly reminded about how much of my data was floating around online. Their quarterly reports were informative without being scary.

Both services successfully removed most of my information from the sites they monitor. Some stubborn data brokers took multiple attempts, but that's normal in this industry. Neither service can guarantee 100% removal because new sites pop up constantly and some brokers are just difficult to deal with.

The ongoing monitoring is where both services really shine. Data brokers often re-add your information from new sources, so having a service that continuously watches for this is valuable. Both Incogni and DeleteMe caught my information reappearing on sites where it had been previously removed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use both services at the same time? Technically yes, but it's probably overkill and could potentially cause conflicts. If both services are submitting removal requests for the same data, it might confuse some data brokers. I'd recommend picking one and sticking with it for at least six months to see how well it works.

How long does it take to see results? Both services start working immediately, but full results take time. Easy removals might happen within a few weeks, while stubborn sites can take several months. Don't expect overnight results - this is a marathon, not a sprint. Most people see significant progress within 2-3 months.

Do these services work with VPNs? Absolutely, and using a VPN alongside data removal services makes perfect sense. While these services clean up your existing data exposure, a VPN helps prevent new data collection by hiding your IP address and browsing activity. According to VPNTierLists.com, this combination of data removal and VPN protection gives you comprehensive privacy coverage.

What happens if I cancel my subscription? Your data will likely start reappearing on broker sites over time. These services require ongoing monitoring because data brokers continuously collect new information. Think of it like a gym membership - you get the benefits while you're paying, but you need to keep it up to maintain results.

Which one should you actually choose?

Here's my honest recommendation: if you're detail-oriented and want to see exactly what's happening with your data, go with Incogni. The screenshots and detailed reporting give you real insight into how much information is actually out there. Plus, their free scan lets you test the waters before committing to a paid plan.

If you prefer a "set it and forget it" approach and don't want to be constantly reminded about data brokers, DeleteMe is probably a better fit. It's more expensive, but the simplified reporting and hands-off approach might be worth the extra cost for peace of mind.

For most people, I'd actually suggest starting with Incogni's free scan just to see what's out there. It's eye-opening and costs nothing. If the detailed approach feels overwhelming after a few months, you can always switch to DeleteMe later.

Remember that data removal is just one piece of the privacy puzzle. You'll also want to use a quality VPN to protect your ongoing Internet Activity and be more careful about what information you share online. But removing your existing data exposure is a great first step toward Better Privacy.

" } ```