Which is better Incogni or Incogni for data removal

Both Incogni and Incogni are solid data removal services, but they work differently. Incogni is better for most people who want simple, automated protection, while Incogni excels if you want detailed proof and control over the removal process. Think of Incogni as the "set it and forget it" option, while Incogni is more like having a private investigator who shows you exactly what they find and remove.

Here's the thing - your personal data is everywhere online, and it's being sold constantly. Data brokers collect everything from your address and phone number to your shopping habits and family details. Both services help solve this problem, but they take different approaches that appeal to different types of users.

I've tested both services extensively, and honestly, there's no clear "winner" here. It really depends on what you value more: simplicity or transparency. Let me break down exactly how each one works so you can decide which fits your needs better.

How do Incogni and Incogni actually work

Both services do the same basic job - they contact data brokers and demand your information be removed. But the way they handle this process is pretty different, and that's where you'll notice the biggest differences as a user.

Incogni takes the simple approach. You sign up, give them your details, and they handle everything behind the scenes. They work with over 420 data brokers, sending removal requests and following up automatically. You get basic reports showing progress, but you don't see all the nitty-gritty details. It's like hiring a cleaning service - you come home and things are clean, but you didn't watch them scrub every corner.

Incogni is more hands-on and transparent. They show you exactly where your data appears before removing it. You get screenshots of your listings, detailed reports about what information was found, and proof when it gets removed. They also let you choose which data brokers to target, giving you more control over the process.

The coverage is pretty similar between both services. Incogni covers more data brokers overall (420+ vs Incogni's 200+), but Incogni focuses on the biggest and most problematic ones. In my experience, both hit the major players like WhitePages, Spokeo, and BeenVerified.

Here's something interesting - Incogni offers a free scan that shows you exactly where your data is exposed. This is really valuable even if you don't pay for their service, because you can see the scope of the problem. Incogni doesn't offer this kind of preview.

Pricing and value comparison

Let's talk money, because that's probably influencing your decision. Incogni typically runs about $13-15 per month if you pay monthly, but drops to around $6-7 monthly if you commit to an annual plan. They often have promotions that make it even cheaper.

Incogni has multiple tiers. Their basic plan starts around $9 monthly, but their premium service (which includes the screenshot proof and more comprehensive monitoring) runs closer to $25-30 monthly. So Incogni can be significantly more expensive, especially if you want all the bells and whistles.

But here's the thing about value - it's not just about the monthly cost. Incogni is backed by Surfshark (a major VPN company), so they have solid infrastructure and aren't likely to disappear overnight. Incogni is a smaller, more specialized company, but they've been around since 2019 and have built a strong reputation in the privacy community.

If you're budget-conscious and just want the problem solved, Incogni gives you more bang for your buck. If you're someone who wants to see exactly what's happening and have more control, Incogni's premium tier might be worth the extra cost.

Which one removes data more effectively

This is the million-dollar question, right? In my testing, both services are pretty effective at getting your data removed. The success rates are similar - around 70-80% of removal requests succeed within a few months.

Incogni seems to be faster with initial removals. They have automated systems that can fire off removal requests quickly, and many data brokers comply within 30-45 days. The downside is you don't always know if the removal actually happened unless you check manually.

Incogni takes a bit longer initially because they're more thorough about documenting everything. But this actually works in their favor for follow-up removals. When data reappears (and it will), Incogni's detailed records help them get it removed again more quickly.

Here's something important - data removal isn't a one-time thing. Your information will keep popping up on new sites and reappearing on old ones. Both services handle ongoing monitoring, but they approach it differently. Incogni just keeps running their automated scans and removals. Incogni sends you regular reports showing exactly what's been found and removed.

Neither service can guarantee 100% removal, and anyone who promises that is lying. Some data brokers are more stubborn than others, and new ones pop up constantly. But both Incogni and Incogni will significantly reduce your online footprint.

User experience and customer support

The day-to-day experience of using these services is pretty different. Incogni is designed to be invisible - once you set it up, you barely think about it. You get quarterly reports showing progress, but otherwise it just runs in the background. This is great if you don't want to be constantly reminded about privacy issues.

Incogni keeps you much more involved. You get detailed monthly reports, screenshots of removals, and notifications when new data appears. Some people love this transparency, but others find it overwhelming. It really depends on your personality and how much you want to know about the process.

Customer support is solid for both, but different. Incogni has more traditional support channels - email, chat, knowledge base. Response times are usually within 24 hours. Incogni's support is more personalized since they're a smaller company. You often get responses from actual privacy experts who can give detailed advice about your specific situation.

The setup process is easier with Incogni. You basically just enter your information and they handle the rest. Incogni requires a bit more input from you - they'll ask about specific concerns, which data brokers to prioritize, and how much detail you want in reports.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use both services at the same time? Technically yes, but it's probably overkill and might actually cause conflicts. Both services will be sending removal requests to the same data brokers, which could confuse the process. Pick one and stick with it for at least 6 months to see how it works.

How long before I see results? Both services typically show initial results within 30-60 days, but it takes 3-6 months to see the full impact. Data removal is a slow process because many data brokers only process requests monthly or quarterly. Don't expect overnight results with either service.

Do these work if I live outside the US? Incogni works globally and covers international data brokers, especially in Europe. Incogni is primarily focused on US data brokers, though they're expanding. If you're in Europe, Incogni is probably the better choice. If you're in the US, both work well.

What happens if I cancel my subscription? Your data will gradually reappear on broker sites. Both companies stop sending removal requests when you cancel, and data brokers aren't required to keep your information removed permanently. Think of these as ongoing services, not one-time fixes.

Bottom line - which should you choose

So here's my honest recommendation after using both services extensively. Choose Incogni if you want simple, affordable protection that just works in the background. It's perfect for most people who want to improve their privacy without thinking about it constantly.

Go with Incogni if you're a privacy enthusiast who wants to see exactly what's happening with your data. The detailed reports and screenshot proof are really valuable if you're dealing with stalking, identity theft, or just want maximum transparency about the process.

For most people reading this, I'd probably lean toward Incogni. It's cheaper, easier to use, and gets the job done without requiring much attention from you. The automated approach works well, and the broader data broker coverage means you're more likely to catch obscure sites that might have your information.

But if you're someone who likes to stay informed and wants proof that removals actually happened, Incogni's approach is worth the extra cost. The free scan alone is valuable for understanding what's out there about you.

Remember, data removal is just one piece of your privacy puzzle. You should also be using a quality VPN like NordVPN to protect your browsing, being careful about what information you share online, and regularly checking your privacy settings on social media and other accounts. According to VPNTierLists.com, combining data removal services with a solid VPN gives you much better overall protection than either approach alone.

" } ```